replace the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs)
once we reach the 2015 deadline. This is still an open
field; for those wishing to set the parameters of the
discussions and ultimately influence the outcome,
the time is now. Health objectives are central to the
Rachel Kiddell-Monroe
MDGs, but the discussions on the future of MDGs
Bryan Collinsworth
mostly take place outside health forums, including
Laura Musselwhite
in discussions on sustainable development. This
In 2001, law students at Yale convinced their
is a key element to note, as it is an increasingly
university, along with the drug company Bristol-
important reality of global governance. Decisions
Myers Squibb (BMS), to take steps to allow
made in non-health institutions or forums, such
a 30-fold price reduction in Africa for a life-
as forums focusing on trade, environment, or
saving HIV/AIDS treatment discovered by Yale
security, can have significant impacts of the health
researchers. Yale had originally licensed this
of populations. It is to better understand this reality
medical breakthrough—stavudine—exclusively to
and to offer recommendations as to how health
BMS, giving the company a patent monopoly to
can be taken better into account in multiple arenas
sell the drug at prices poor Africans simply couldn’t
afford. Students pushed Yale and BMS to allow
low-cost generic versions in South Africa, and the
results were dramatic. As Dr. Eric Goemaere of
honour of being one of its commissioners, and I am
happy to invite the readers of the Health Diplomacy
“Today, 12,000 patients are on ARVs [anti-
was recently published by the Commission.
retrovirals] in Khayelitsha and an estimated
800,000 nationwide. This is in great deal thanks
to a few courageous and idealistic Yale students
who managed to dig a first small hole in the IP
[intellectual property] fortress. No one in that time
could have imagined it would make the fortress
collapse, change public opinion and have such
consequences on survival of millions of people.”a rolE for univErsitiEsStavudine was not an isolated case: 10 million
people lack access to essential medicines each
year, largely due to high prices created by patent
monopolies. The Yale students’ key insight was
that universities, as major contributors to medical
research, had a responsibility to become part
Published by the Centre for Trade Policy and Law
1125 Colonel By Drive | Ottawa, Ontario | K1S 5B6 | www.ctpl.ca
of the solution rather than part of the problem.
getting fired up about the impact of health research
They formed the non-profit Universities Allied for
and licensing policies in their own countries.
Essential Medicines (UAEM) as a student-driven
Students in Brazil have started UAEM chapters,
movement to promote equitable global access and
devising locally appropriate ways to highlight
innovation in publicly funded medical research.
universities’ role in promoting global access to
Through UAEM’s advocacy, universities that license
essential medicines. Supporting these students is
medical research to industry have now begun to
a key part of UAEM’s mission: we seek to empower
include requirements for generic production or
students worldwide to advocate for health access,
“at cost” provisions for low- and middle-income
thereby developing new global health leaders.
countries. These “global access” provisions lower
By working with universities to make sure medical
the price of the final products for poor patients, and
discoveries reach those in need, students also
have been adopted by leading institutions including
ensure that these institutions respect their public
Harvard, Yale, the University of British Columbia,
mission and keep the interests of patients above
and the US National Institutes for Health (NIH). Ten
those of profit. Globally, students will make
Nobel Laureates—among them, Desmond Tutu of
sure that governments hear the same message.
South Africa and MSF—also support this strategy.
As students told delegates at a UN meeting in
New York last September, even chronic “non-
communicable” diseases now disproportionately
While over 30 research institutions worldwide
strike youth in the Global South. Youth from around
have endorsed a “Statement of Principles and
the world can and must contribute solutions to
Strategies” supporting global access to their
these health challenges, and those solutions must
medical discoveries, the students of UAEM want to
include access to life-saving medicines discovered
ensure that this translates into real-world impact.
The statement itself should be strengthened, and
individual universities can adopt more robust
policies. Most importantly, however, universities
Rachel Kiddell-Monroe is President of UAEM
must demonstrate that they are regularly including
(www.essentialmedicine.org). Previously, Rachel
global access provisions in their licensing
worked for over 15 years with Médecins Sans
negotiations with pharmaceutical companies.
Frontières as Head of Mission in the Great Lakes
Region and the Horn of Africa and throughout Latin
Improving the transparency of universities and
America. She was also the Canadian Director of
the MSF’s Access to Medicines Campaign.
their licensing practices is critical. Not only do
universities need to ensure affordable access to
Bryan Collinsworth is Executive Director of UAEM,
and Laura Musselwhite is a fourth-year medical
their medical breakthroughs, but they also need
to show that they are committing resources, both
human and financial, to research on “neglected
diseases.” It is not just the pharmaceutical industry
that neglects devastating illnesses like malaria and
Chagas disease—which predominantly affect poor
populations—to pursue more profitable research.
Sadly, academic scientists and institutions also
neglect them. Universities must invest in research
on neglected diseases to begin to address the
huge inequity in treatments available for poor
patients in the Global South. studEnt movEmEnt sprEading to global southSince the stavudine case, UAEM has grown
into a global network that is present on over 70
campuses worldwide and includes students of law,
medicine, science, and public health. This growth
includes students in the Global South, who are
CRÉATION INTERVENTIONS BUTS DE L'ASSOCIATION L'Association d'Aide Aux Victimes des Accidents des PRÉVENIR les Citoyens des dangers de certains Médicaments a été fondée en 1992, suite au nombre de DEVANT L'AMPLEUR DES MASSACRES, médicaments aux effets indésirables et paradoxaux très graves suicides de plus en plus élevés en France , imputables aux SUICI
City & County of San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency Citizens’ Advisory Council (CAC) Notice of Regular Meeting and Agenda Thursday, May 3, 2007 at 5:30 p.m. 1 South Van Ness Avenue, Conference Room 3074 San Francisco, California Members: Daniel Murphy (Chair), Steve Ferrario (Vice Chair), Mary Burns, Sue Cauthen, Art Cimento, Joan Downey, Emily Drenn